Thanksgiving & Pardons: Turkeys and Famous Pardons

Thanksgiving tradition sees the president of the United States pardoning a turkey.  Sometimes a pair of turkeys.  They come from the National Turkey Federation.

Spared from the dinner table, the turkeys go to a safe home at Virginia Tech.  They live out their life under the care of the school’s Animal and Poultry Science Department.  Their post pardon life even includes veterinary care.

Around the end of the year and the end of their terms, presidents and governors also consider a long list of folks who want a real life pardon.

What is a Pardon?

Generally speaking pardons are the act of forgiving or being forgiven for an error or an offense.

The U.S. Constitution gives the President of the United States power to grant “reprieves and pardons” for offenses against the United States.  Most states allow their governors to pardon those running afoul of state level wrongs.

Presidents can also commute sentences, essentially reducing them or imposing various conditions, but that’s a slightly different topic.

Usually there is a process involving an application, and there’s actually a pardon attorney in the executive branch to review pardons and advise the President.  In the end granting pardons rests solely in the discretion of the President.

Notable Pardons

President Donald Trump granted 74 pardons and 70 commutations in the final hours of his presidency.  Pardons included longtime aid Steven Bannon and fundraiser Elliot Briody.  Just one hour before Trump left office he pardoned Albert Pirro, Jr.  Pirro is the ex husband of Fox Network host and Trump friend Jeanine Pirro.  The “ex” had been convicted on charges of tax evasion and conspiracy.  Trump pardons include that of Michael Ashley, convicted of bank fraud connected to the 2009 failure of a major mortgage company.  Trump also pardoned Susan B. Anthony, who was tried in 1872 in Rochester, N.Y. for breaking the then existing law allowing only men to vote.

President Joseph Biden has used the pardon, twice for people convicted of what were called minor drug charges.  Another pardon went to former secret service agent Abraham Bolden, Sr., convicted in the 1960’s of selling a secret service file.  Bolden was 86 years old when pardoned.

When President Barack Obama left office on January 20, 2017, he had granted only 212 pardons over the course of his 8 years in office.  That, despite nearly 3,414 pardon applications submitted.

President Obama granted 1,715 commutations over the term of his presidency, more than any president in U.S. history, unless you count 13,000 draft dodgers and or deserters during the Vietnam War era granted clemency by president Gerald Ford.

In President Obama’s final week in office he commuted the prison sentence of Chelsea Manning, the former U.S. Army intelligence analyst who had been sentenced to 35 years behind bars for handing over secret documents to notorious Wikileaks.

Three Famous Pardons

• In 1974 President Gerald Ford pardoned his predecessor, Richard M. Nixon for conduct surrounding the Watergate scandal even though Nixon had not been convicted or even charged with any specific crime.  Nixon had resigned as the House Judiciary Committee drew up articles of impeachment.
• On January 20, 2001, the last day of his presidency, Bill Clinton pardoned 140 people, including FALN terrorists and billionaire contributor Marc Rich.
• Six Reagan administration officials accused and/or convicted in connection with the Iran-Contra matter were pardoned by President George H.W. Bush one month before the end of his term.

Justice Department guidelines require waiting five years after conviction or release to apply for a pardon.  But the president can grant a pardon at any time.  President Ford pardoned Nixon prior to formal criminal charges.

State Level Pardons

Most governors also hold pardon power.

Not as lucky as the Thanksgiving turkey, Pamela Smart has never been pardoned.  She continues to serve a life sentence without parole for her role behind the murder of husband Greg Smart in Derry, NH.  Repeated requests for a pardon found their way into the governor’s trash barrel.  Governor Chris Sununu, considered a law and order supporter even if the youngest governor in the U.S., is highly doubtful to ever ink a pardon for Smart.  Before him, Governor Maggie Hassan said “never” to a Smart pardon.

Coming to the end of his time as governor of Massachusetts, Governor Charles Baker announced six pardons including two people associated with the Fells Acres Day Care child molestation case of the 1980s. Gerald Amirault and Cheryl Amirault LeFave had been convicted in the notorious scandal.  Gerald Amirault was paroled in 2004 after serving 18 years in prison.  Cheryl Amirault’s sentence was overturned in 1995.  She had served eight years in prison.

Previously, Deval Patrick took office as governor in January of 2007 and never pardoned anyone until November, 2014, when he pardoned four people.  One was a 43-year-old cancer survivor who served two years on a charge stemming from possession of a small bag of marijuana.  The pardon cleared the man’s record allowing him to coach basketball.

Pardons find little popularity in New Hampshire.  Governor John Sununu who served from 1983 through 1989 issued 17 pardons.  But then, between 1990 and 2007, only three people were pardoned.

Pardons: The “Oops” Factor

Massachusetts Governor Michael Dukakis in 1976 pardoned Edward Brown, convicted of assault with a dangerous weapon and armed robbery in connection with an attack on a man in Somerville.  Brown moved to New Hampshire, where he and his wife refused to pay federal income taxes, failed to participate in their trial, and then, after conviction, staged a lengthy standoff with feds.  The Browns now spend holidays in a federal penitentiary.

You can even be pardoned after you’re dead.  President Clinton pardoned Henry O. Flipper 59 years after the former military officer’s death.  Flipper was court marshaled for embezzlement of commissary funds.

Pardon Me

Whether its a turkey or a person, pardons represent an end run around the system.  The turkey’s life is spared the butcher’s axe.  Political pardons operate outside of the usual channels of criminal justice either erasing a past conviction, or in some cases preventing prosecution.

Attorney Andrew D. Myers is a personal injury and bankruptcy attorney licensed in Massachusetts and New Hampshire who sometimes writes on other legal issues.

Views: 351